As we know, Jody was often very controlling over Janie. He shows his colors when he says "‘mah wife don't know nothin' ‘bout no speech-makin'. Ah never married her for nothin' lak dat. She's uh woman and her place is in de home.' (Hurston 43). He often degraded Janie but at the same time put her on a pedestal as his wife. Jody also says, "Somebody got to think for women and chillun and chickens and cows. I god, they sho don't think none theirselves'"(71). Later on in the story we discover that Tea Cake is also very domineering over Janie. He would often leave her and manipulate her, just like when he stole her money and was gone all day spending it. He says he will get her money back but again is M.I.A. He ends up getting the money and gaining back Janie's trust, all while gaining more opportunity for manipulation. Janie ends up falling deep in love with Tea Cake, which often leads to vulnerability. Tea Cake represents another example of male dominance in Janie's life.
Nunkie represents how men often lie and manipulate women, Tea Cake was fooling around with her but it could be more than that. Janie is so fond of him that she would always believe him. Many men cheat on their wives and their wives have no idea because they are manipulated so much. Janie seems to be attracted to the more controlling men.
The color purple is a perfect example of male dominance; it is about a young African American girl who is forced to live with a man who was called Mister, and was abused all her life and told what to do all the time. This is an excerpt about some characters in the novel:"Sofia, who is Harpo’s wife, is a strong headed and short tempered woman, and for this time period that wasn’t the expected behavior of women. Women were supposed to follow everything that their husbands said and this shows how the genders roles and switched in parts of this novel."
“All your children so clean, she say, would you like to work for me, be my maid?
Sofia say, I say, Hell no.
She say, What you say?
Sofia say, Hell no.
Mayor look at Sofia, push his wife out the way. Stick out his chest. Girl, what you say to Miss Millie?
Sofia say, I say, Hell no.
He slap her.
I stop telling it right there.
Squeak on the edge of her seat. She wait. Look down my throat some more.
No need to say no more, Mr._____ say. You know what happen is somebody slap Sofia.
Squeak go white as a sheet. Naw, she say.
Naw nothing, I say. Sofia knock the man down.
The polices come, start slinging the children off the mayor, bang they heads together. Sofia really start to fight. They drag her to the ground.” (Walker 90-91)
http://thecolorpurplepd9.blogspot.com/2012/10/the-color-purple-excerpt.html?m=1
ReplyDeleteI agree with your statement Jody was a very controlling character in the novel. In one of my post I explained how jody was a narcissistic person who felt empowered by ones lack of power. Jody treated Janie with this mindset which is the reason why their marriage was unsuccessful.
ReplyDeleteI agree with you Javan, the author illustrates Janie as being subconsciously drawn into men who will take charge over her. In each relationship she has been involved in her husbands dominate over her until she finally runs away, or falls for a new suitor. Janie as well as other women fall into mens deceitful trap and suffer their dominance. Janie has the potential to be a strong individual but she relies to heavily on the men in her life, explaining further why she forgives Tea Cakes so easily each time. Janie wants to be free yet she sticks by the side of men who dominate over her.
ReplyDeleteThe Color Purple is one of my favorite books! If books could have siblings, The Color Purple and Their Eyes Were Watching God would definitely be sisters. The character of Sophia is very much like Janie in the way they are both powerful women for their time period. However, by this excerpt alone we see how she is more hard-headed while Janie shows more submissiveness to the men in her life.
ReplyDeleteThe marriage of Janie and Jody Starks is a perfect example of male dominance in the society of the late 1800s/early 1900s. I also talked about this same topic in my blog post, discussing how male dominance was, is and may continue to be a major issue in our world, unless something is done about it. Also, I like how you used an outside example of literature, which significantly connected to Their Eyes Were Watching God.
ReplyDelete